Wilton favor tins are so much fun to embellish. For about $19 you can get a bucket of 30 at Michaels or Hobby Lobby. Of course, with a coupon, you can get them for about half of that. You usually find them with the wedding favors. They're great for little candies or I'm thinking of maybe a silver dollar in the stocking at Christmas.
We used the Deer Friends stamp set along with the scallop circle punch, and 1-3/8", 1-1/4" and 1" circle punches.
When you're trying to get paper to stick to a round surface, gravity works against you and it becomes easily undone. Even red sticky strip can come loose. A wet glue works better, and our new Tombow multi-purpose adhesive worked perfectly.